Synopsis
Respond proportionately when a patient wants to leave or leaves unexpectedly, distinguish detention from treatment authority and document the correct emergency legal basis and safeguards.
- The Mental Health Act 1983 and Mental Capacity Act 2005 framework discussed here applies to England and Wales; Scotland and Northern Ireland have different legislation.
- A patient with capacity may make an unwise decision, including declining recommended medical treatment, unless another lawful power applies.
- Assess capacity for the particular decision at the relevant time after providing practical communication and decision support.
- MHA section 5 holding powers apply to eligible hospital inpatients, not ordinary emergency-department attendees who have not been admitted.
- Section 5(2) provides up to seventy-two hours for the authorised clinician's holding power; section 5(4) is a limited nursing power for up to six hours or earlier authorised clinician arrival.
- Section 5 detention does not itself authorise medical treatment without consent; establish separate treatment authority.
- MCA restraint must be necessary to prevent harm to the person and proportionate to the likelihood and seriousness of that harm.
- Document current restrictions, alternatives, time limits and reassessment; a legal form does not replace continuing clinical judgement.